Member Login

Lost your password?

Not a member yet? Sign Up!

Possessing a Stolen Handgun with a Felony Record Brings 10 year Sentence

August 21, 2014

MugShot_Charlie CarlisleCharlie Carlisle, Sr., of Donaldson was sentenced Wednesday, August 20, in Marshall Superior Court number 1 to 10 years imprisonment for possessing a handgun as a serious violent felon. In open court, Carlisle admitted that on December 19, 2013, he possessed a handgun and sold it to another individual, and that he had at least one felony conviction in his past.

Judge Robert O. Bowen approved an agreement reached between Chief Deputy Prosecuting Attorney Nelson Chipman and defense attorney Richard Ballard of Knox, which provided that upon a plea of guilty to the charge a sentence of 10 years imprisonment in the Indiana Department of Corrections would be imposed, four years of the sentence would be suspended, and Carlisle could argue to have his sentence served on home detention.

Chipman argued against the home detention possibility noting Community Corrections Director Ward Byers had rejected Carlisle’s request. In addition, Marshall County Probation Officer Abby Caswell’s Pre-sentence Investigation and Written Report pointed to that the nature of the offense, Carlisle’s background and his answers to some of her questions led her to recommend that home detention be denied. After hearing all of the evidence, Judge Bowen agreed with the State and denied the home detention request and ordered Carlisle remanded to the Sheriff for transport to the Department of Corrections.

The case began on December 19, 2013 when Patrolman Travis Oneal of the Marshall County Sheriff’s Department was dispatched to a residence on Lilac Road. Two individuals there reported purchasing a handgun from Carlisle and wanted to check to make sure it was not stolen. Oneal’s investigation revealed that indeed the handgun had been reported stolen in Sarasota County, Florida. Further investigation revealed that Carlisle had a felony record, one of which was a B felony burglary which by law designated him as a serious violent felon. It is unlawful for any serious violent felon to possess any type of gun, operable or not, registered or not.

After allowing Carlisle to explain his version of the events, Oneal arrested him and he has been held in the Marshall County Jail since December 20, 2013, awaiting disposition.

Chipman expressed his appreciation to the citizens that made the call to make sure the gun was legal, which it was not, and praised Oneal for a thorough investigation.


3 Responses to “ Possessing a Stolen Handgun with a Felony Record Brings 10 year Sentence ”

  1. Thor on August 30, 2014 at 8:26 pm

    Hi Andrew,

    Actually motor vehicles prove every year that they are far more deadly. More people are killed with baseball bats than rifles (including those scary ‘assault’ rifles) but you don’t see anyone trying to make it illegal to drive to a baseball game.

    It was illegal for this person to have a firearm of any kind. Seems the law worked thanks to some responsible citizens.

    Passing more legislation to be run by state bureaucracies making it more difficult or expensive for law abiding citizens to possess defensive arms would have done nothing to stop this (or any) criminal.

  2. Andrew on August 25, 2014 at 5:02 am

    I’m not much of a gun control person, and admittedly I don’t understand the whole registration process, having not ever owned a gun.

    My understanding is that the loophole in catching people like that is that private sales are not regulated and require no paperwork to transpire. I may be wrong about this.

    If one was to apply the same standard to guns as to owning and operating a motor vehicle (which are just as deadly) requiring the title to be registered with the state, much of this would be taken care of by itself.

  3. Thor on August 24, 2014 at 9:03 pm

    Kudos on the people for calling in, it is always a good idea to ask for ID when doing this kind of a transaction…and if they have shown up with a handgun to sell ask for their license to carry a handgun too. If they don’t have those call the police and let them deal with it.