Member Login

Lost your password?

Not a member yet? Sign Up!

Carnegie Pleads Guilty to 3 Charges, Sentenced to 9 Years

April 18, 2018

MugShot_Vinnie Carnigie

54 year old Vincent S. Carnegie of Argos appeared in Marshall Superior Court I Wednesday morning with his attorney Tom Black for a plea agreement.

Carnegie’s case dates back to May 26, 2017.  The Probable Cause Affidavit accuses Carnegie of breaking and entering his former girlfriend’s home and then driving her between Plymouth and Argos where she eventually escaped and a passing sheriff’s deputy found her.  Later in the day police located Carnegie on King Road just north of 9th Road.  He was armed with a handgun, at times aiming it at officer and threatened to kill himself.  In a skirmish with officer Carnegie shot himself and was airlifted from the scene to the trauma center in South Bend.

Vinnie Carnegie also had an unrelated charge from 2015 of Theft from Newmar Corp. in Nappanee.  It was alleged that he drove a 2016 RV estimated to cost $500,000 off the lot.

The final case was a misdemeanor battery and domestic battery from an incident at the Eagles Lodge a few days prior to the May 26th incident.

Carnegie was in court last November for a plea agreement where he was expected to plead guilty to burglary and theft with the remaining charges being dismissed.  In the courtroom he withdrew his guilty plea commenting that he would not admit guilt to the crimes.

On Wednesday, April 18th Superior Court I Judge Robert Bowen told Carnegie he had the right to a trial and that one was set for the near future.  After reading the terms of the plea agreement Judge Bowen asked Carnegie if he understood the terms, and he said yes.  He told him the charges and sentencing for the three crimes: Theft as a level 5 felony sentenced to 3 years; Burglary as a level 4 felony sentenced to 6 years and Resisting Law Enforcement as a level 6 felony with a 1 year sentence. Carnegie admitted guilt to all three charges with the kidnapping, auto theft, pointing a firearm and the battery charges being dismissed.

The Burglary and Theft charges will run consecutively, while the Resisting Law Enforcement will run concurrently to the Burglary charge, meaning 9 years in prison.  Carnegie will have to serve 75% of his sentence.  He has already been incarcerated for 321 days and those days will be applied to his time under Indiana law.   He was also charged a $1 fine and costs for each case and will not serve probation upon his release.

A $3,000 cash bond posed for the theft of the RV charge will be applied to his past due child support obligation as the Newmar Corporation was reimbursed by insurance and regained possession of their RV.

One Response to “ Carnegie Pleads Guilty to 3 Charges, Sentenced to 9 Years ”

  1. sbmear on April 20, 2018 at 1:26 pm

    Im wondering what our courts are thinking? We need to deter people from committing crimes if possible, however I have noticed for quite some time now, people using or selling drugs, or committing other types of crimes, will have several crimes they are arrestted for and when it comes down to it, half of the crimes are dropped for an agreement, then the sentense is suspended and given some substanually less time or maybe just probation. How is this a deterent? We need stronger lawyers and judges. Do as other cities and states, put them to work cleaning up the highways, doing something instead of working out and playing cards in jail. There are people with ankle bracelets playing golf in the daytime when they are being allowed to go to work while on probabtion. Quit making deals, its no ownder Marshall county has the drug problems they do…even if they are caught they will geta lesser sentence and its not a big deal to them compared to the money they make.